Worst Star Wars Episode

txmielnik

Diabloii.Net Member
Worst Star Wars Episode

Now that most people have seen episode 3. I was wondering which episode you think was the worst, in my opinion it was episode one :eek: by far.
 

Wrathchild

Diabloii.Net Member
txmielnik said:
Now that most people have seen episode 3. I was wondering which episode you think was the worst, in my opinion it was episode one :eek: by far.
true. 1 was good, but didn't have the typical star wars action in it. episode 3 was the best, though it wasnt as fun to watch it as episode 2, since it was so sad.

you should've made a poll of this
 

Beowulf

Diabloii.Net Member
Wrathchild said:
true. 1 was good, but didn't have the typical star wars action in it. episode 3 was the best, though it wasnt as fun to watch it as episode 2, since it was so sad.

you should've made a poll of this
Umm there are 3 more you know.
 

Wrathchild

Diabloii.Net Member
Beowulf said:
Umm there are 3 more you know.
well yeah but i never really thought of em as episodes. the old three are good as well, but I don't want to compare them to the new ones
 

Beowulf

Diabloii.Net Member
Wrathchild said:
well yeah but i never really thought of em as episodes. the old three are good as well, but I don't want to compare them to the new ones
They are now refered to as episode IV, V and VI.
 

SelfBaisResistor

Diabloii.Net Member
Ash Housewares said:
Episode II had no redeeming qualities
Ummm, Christopher Lee. They should have given Dooku a bigger role. I'm also gonna agree that II was the one I liked the least. Cheesy love sense and Anakin should have been less of a whiner.
 

ilkori

Diabloii.Net Member
II would make a great video game... done just like the movie. It had platformers and everything.
 

Elcold

Diabloii.Net Member
ilkori said:
II would make a great video game... done just like the movie. It had platformers and everything.
Its also the only movie they didnt make a video game out of, ironic :lol: .
 

plasmo

Diabloii.Net Member
Episode I has IMHO the best lightsaber battle; the one at the end with Maul. Good timing, lots of fun little elements (like opening the door by force-throwing an object, tapping on the laser dividers with his lightsaber, etc), and most important of all, a pulled-back camera. Most of the other films, even III, have the camera so tight you can't tell if the actors are actually any good or not. What a waste; you practice sword fighting for months and then the director puts the camera so close that all you see are hands.

Episode I also had the pod race, which was one of the greatest examples of surround sound ever.

Episode II was pretty, well, blah. Although Yoda pulling out his lightsabre was probably the greatest cinematic moment of all time (Maul lighting his second blade was pretty cool too, though, as are Grevious' various poses with four).

Both I and II had many horrific moments, though, so they kinda tie there (acting, storyline, dialogue, ugh).

So, yeah, Episode II was the worst.
 

dirkdig

Diabloii.Net Member
2 doesn't deserve the title of star wars. It didn't even really have a coherent plot. It begins with separitist systems breaking off from the republic and the jedi losing control, and it ends with the sep systems breaking off from the republic and the jedi losing control. The battle is meaningless, and makes the jedi look weak, losing to a bunch of crappy droids. The love story is poorly scripted and as a result poorly acted as well, and Anakin is almost as annoying as Jar-Jar.
 

AeroJonesy

Diabloii.Net Member
I thought I was the worst because it had the least impact on the plot. It just seemed unnecessary. The scene from II where Anakin goes on a rampage in the Tusken village is one of the most memorable scenes for me, out of episodes I, II, and III.
 

Chynobi

Diabloii.Net Member
Now Revenge of the Sith is released it shouldnt be seen as episodes just one big saga.


Anyway the worst episode.... Hmm I cant really say there was one.
 

AeroJonesy

Diabloii.Net Member
So who can't wait until all of them are out on DVD, and there can be a giant watch 'em all in a row party? By then, Lucas should have re-mastered IV, V, and VI a couple more times, and they'll be in 5-D.
 

nrabbit

Diabloii.Net Member
the first one is horrible. The empire strkies back and the lat one are the best (don't know the original name of the 6th in english :rolleyes: )
 
Top