Thorns aura = God-mode?

Shucandi

Diabloii.Net Member
Thorns aura = God-mode?

i was wondering if thorns aura work in pvp?
it sounds to good to be true that it return 100% dmg back to mele attack in pvp?

and if it does work in pvp? will it have any effekt on skills such as ww and smite?
 

Mcwhopper

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

It might : But it would then return 1/6 of the damage you actually received. Not all that great :)
 

Nimbostratus

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

Damage returned% is seriously crippled in PVP

1/6 PVP penalty from opponent
Any damage reduction you have
1/10 damage return penalty
1/6 PVP penalty (I think)
Any damage reduction your opponent has
 

Shucandi

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

Damage returned% is seriously crippled in PVP

1/6 PVP penalty from opponent
Any damage reduction you have
1/10 damage return penalty
1/6 PVP penalty (I think)
Any damage reduction your opponent has

well as i see it ... then on http://www.battle.net/diablo2exp/skills/paladin-offense.shtml#thorns

on arrea summit it says 1/10 dmg on pvp... so if i have a lvl 21 thorns on my bramble it will return 1050 % dmg to monsters,,, but only 150% dmg returned to players because the penalty is 1/10... so 1050 / 10 = 150 % dmg returned in pvp...

am i right?


 

krischan

Europe Trade Moderator
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

No, it goes through the pvp reduction a second time, as it's an attack by based on an attack of your enemy. BTW, 1/10 of 1050 is 105, not 150 :azn:.
 

omgwtfbbqpwned

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

Nimbostratus got it right. Too many reductions makes it useless... unless you're talking about pets (which do not count as characters and thus do not get some reduction bonuses). Then it mildly works.
 

Shucandi

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

No, it goes through the pvp reduction a second time, as it's an attack by based on an attack of your enemy. BTW, 1/10 of 1050 is 105, not 150 :azn:.

ya so what if it based on the attacks from the enemy,, thats the point of this.. lol xD so if a player attacks u, and he give u 1000 dmg then it will be returned as 1050 dmg to him,, a eye for a eye...


 

Mcwhopper

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

No it will be returned as like 1 damage:
he does 1000 damage : 1/6 of that arrives at you.
1000/6 bounces back: 1/6 of that arrives at your opponent
He will receive 1000/36 damage, and this is not taking into account any dr :)
 

omgwtfbbqpwned

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

^ You forgot the additional 1/10 penalty.

I don't think you're quite getting the concept Shucandi... it's gets reduced by 1/6, 1/10, 1/6, making any returned damage almost negligible.
 

Nimbostratus

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

Assume the enemy hits you with an attack doing 5K damage. You have level 25 Thorns, which returns 1210% damage.

-Enemy damage gets reduced to 1/6 by PVP penalty: 5000/6 = 833 damage
-Any damage reduction on you reduces the damage taken. But let's assume you want to maximize the thorns damage and thus have no reduction. <no change>
-Thorns return is 1210%: 833 x 13.1 = 10912 damage
-1/10 reduction for damage returned%: 833/10 = 1091 damage
-1/6 PVP penalty again: 182 damage
-Any damage reduction your opponent has. Assume 50%: 91 damage

So with a level 25 thorns, you're taking 833 damage and only returning 91. Ouch.

(EDIT: almost forgot the thorns% the first time. Fixed.)
 

omgwtfbbqpwned

Diabloii.Net Member
Re: Thorns aura = God-mode?

No, and same with minions, which is why damage returns on with them. Mostly minions, because reviving mercs just for a PvP strategy is heavy $$$.
 
Top