Re: Halloween Saw themed Mafia game.
Thanks for another fun game TC!
There seemed to be some really fun roles, but I don't think a lot of the fun stuff happened. Leo didn't become mafia Don. The pro-town showing mafia member was never successfully investigated. Peter Straham was never lynched. Jeff Reinhart never killed a vote locker (that may have been by choice).
I'm curious what Adam Faulker's pictures would have shown, had that role stayed alive at the end.
The paranoid cop showing himself as pro-town was a nice touch. I'm not a fan of cops investigating themselves, ever, and I like how you deliberately altered their own result to make that a "wasted night."
The barkeep, as always, is a spectacular role.
What was the purpose of the even/odd hitmen? I gather it could have influenced the photographs shown.
I was right about Lynn Denlon being linked to another player. Howerver, I initially guess it was linked to Jigsaw. If Jigsaw died, I expected to be killed as well.
I was wondering if the Lynn Denlon role could have healed Art Blank, Eric Matthews, or Dr. Gordon. The wording of my role caused me to imply I could not help them, since harm had already come to them. Furthermore, Art and Eric's troubles seemed to be curable with time while Lynn Denlon had no association with Dr. Gordon in the movies, so I deemed a rescue to be improbable and just an attempt by mafia to get the real doc to come forward.
In the end, I think I roleclaimed at the right time. I felt the town had enough pieces to complete the puzzle. I knew my earlier questioning of Sathoris would make me a target to both townies looking for scum and mafia looking for power roles, so I wanted to get my information out in the open.
Plus, I felt that the mafia's target the next night would give a hint as to which role they feared most. I'm a bit surprised a doc was targeted, over what I consider to be much more powerful roles, but I guess TC's lists had much influence here.
Out of curiosity, what were the lists given to Amanda each night and what hints did you give on each role?
I'm certainly glad I claimed before I was killed. Two night kills would have caused lots of theorycrafting, on top of the cult idea. A husband/wife pair dying the same night kept scum hunting on track.
