Taurgon said:
I once had to toss a Gheeds because I only had two characters that could enter Hell and they both had a charm, so make sure you always have a standby character that can pick one up, because you never know when they will drop.
There's a way to avoid this, but it is risky:
* Make sure the game in which you found the new Gheed's has been up for at least 5 minutes.
* Have your character hold one of the charms, leave the other on the ground.
* Leave the game and create a new game, any difficulty.
* Drop the Gheed's in this new game as soo as you get in, and then leave immediately.
* (Quickly) bring a different character into the second game to pick up the charm. Leave in a timely manner, but no real rush (you can wait around a minute if you think you'll get a realm down otherwise).
* Use the first character to re-enter the first game and pick up the Gheed's you left there.
I've done this a few times with no troubles, but
your mileage may vary! It's safest to have a trusted friend to help you out, or ask in one of the stickied help threads on these forums, but if you can't find anyone to help, this may be worth a shot.