I think poison and light damage on charms negate your deadly strike on progectiles~ arrows
gah. another one....
I believe this is a rumor that has been taken care of a multitude of times on these forums...oO
Poison/Elemental charms do -not- negate any damage.
quite. this is one of the most persistant and irritating b.net myths. it ranks up there with griffons/facets and traps.
i think it got started because someone realised that a successful Critical Strike roll had no effect whatsoever on their pdsc damage, only on the physical damage component of their attack. given that a pdsc bowazon is unlikely to be a glass-cannon max phys-damage build, the critical strike offered a much lower return on investment.
in this sense, yes, critical strike and pdsc's don't work together very well. but the use of an elemental damage source hardly "negates" ones critical strike.
the reciprocal here is: max damage charms. these do indeed, afaik, have their bonus boosted by a successful Critical Strike roll. a much more harmonious relationship between skills and equipment, no?
but to repeat: pdsc's do not "negate" ones critical strke, they merely fail to benefit from it.
as to the duped/perm/etc argument here. i think it's a lot easier to put together a respectable max/ar/XxX charmset that doesn't require a trade-screen-boogie than it is to get worthwhile PvP damage from pdsc's that are equally durable. i have some rather nice max charms i'v collected over time, they are far from perfect 3/20/20's, but it's mostly the +3 max that we
really want. anything else is gravy.