I think most just don't care for his arrogant demeanor. I think his Shaman guide has merit and I didn't really have any problems with him until he posted his "guide" on Thorns and damage return. It was all non-tested theory-crafting that he passed off as solid info. Spreading bad info is a D2 war crime imo.
mmm... I've never had a problem against him. I bicker ovre builds with him like I pretty much do to every one else, I'm equally annoying to all! lol =D
If anything, I found he puts more testing and clarification into most shizzle than most ppl, and this is from over the years of reading other forum threads he's done... if anything it's other ppl that dont have their facts straight... like the 2, 3, 4- frame Were-sin, who clarified that? he did.
Many guides seem to make stuff up. ie: It had been stated as fact that frw doesn't affect Trang "ghoul lord" in one of the necro guides, well.. me and Sonny just ran a test a while ago proving otherwise and it deffinitely makes a dramatic difference >.< the lieees! lol
Well it really depends. Its alot of theory mostly, because for a BvC to beat a shaman like that, he needs:
1) 1 handed W/S setup
2) High Stacked Resists / Sorb
3) High Leech
All good BvC's will have high stacked resists. Therefore, your fissures are gonna be guaranteed 75%+ reduced, which is ok though... 'cause I've used ~4k fissures on switch with my FC bear and even 25% of its potential can drop most barbs that roll through it.
Yeah, like you said though... even if they are 2-hand, if they grab some hellmouths, a dwarf, and some spurs gl lol.
Tele-poking them on the off whirl I'll use time to time, but it's really risky... if you think they're coming outta ww and u try to make a jump then they whirl right through you that could be your death.. or free health for them and your in a world of pain. With lvl 52 Griz & 49 HoW, even I can't kill most in less than 3 hits sad to say, so it is a strategy... not always the most reliable though : /
The only thing I might not be right about is how the 1/10 and 1/6 pvp penalties apply for each different thorns effect, but it doesn't really matter for the most part. Thorns on a high HP summon will kill people. Thorns on a player will not.
Yeah I think you're right about the thorns... thorns suffers some crazy pvp penalties with the new patch let alone DR & life leech, so it's pretty much jack against other duelests. But like you said, Summons have 0% DR allowing the full potential life to be returned... and the thorns is only gonna be proportional to its total hit points. That's why I was gonna test whether it'd be better off to go Bramble + edge with oak.. for higher total hp grizzly, or Bramble + edge with lvl 30 SoB if the extra HP's don't really matter.
:thumbsup: